Credits
Mitch
Albers developed this lesson.
Goals
Students will investigate the properties
of water and develop an understanding of how water behaves in a lake
environment. Wet laboratory and WOW data experiments demonstrate the
unique properties of water and its importance to lakes and living things.
Introduction
Water is
essential to life on earth and totally dominates the chemical composition
of all organisms. The characteristics of water regulate a lake's metabolism.
Its unique thermal-density properties, specific
heat, and freezing point allow the formation of a stratified
environment that controls the chemical and biological properties of
lakes.
Students can meet the goals for this lesson
by completing either a directed study or student inquiry lesson. The directed
study lesson guides students through two worksheets. One worksheet corresponds
to a lab experiment on temperature density stratification. Students analyze
WOW data on the second worksheet. Students need to print both worksheets.
The directed study lesson can be accessed
in the student section of WOW under the title "Studying
the Properties of Water."
The student inquiry lesson places students
as chemistry teachers. It challenges students to use WOW data and a
lab experiment to teach about typical summer and winter lake profiles.
The end product is a written report, poster, oral report, or multi-media
presentation.
The directed study lesson can be found
in the student section of WOW under the title "Investigating
the Properties of Water."
Outcomes
Students will:
- Understand the unique properties of water
and apply them to a lake environment.
- Retrieve real-time and historical data
obtained from WOW lakes.
- Explain how WOW data illustrates some
properties of water.
Keywords
Polarity,
hydrogen
bonds, cohesion,
surface tension,
adhesion,
capillary
action, density,
specific
heat, neuston,
heat
of vaporization, universal
solvent
Prerequisites
Students need a basic understanding of chemistry
and basic spreadsheet and graphing skills. They should also be able to
retrieve WOW data prior to completing this lesson.
Materials/Resources/Software
- Excel spreadsheet, Internet Access, Web Browser, Netscape version
4.07, MSIE version 4.0 w/Java 1.1.1 plug-in
- Two 5-10 gallon aquaria
- Plastic rulers
- Thermometers
- Red food coloring
- 2 gallon carboy with valve/tygon tube/U-tube assembly
- Salt
- Pasteur pipettes
- 5 gallons of refrigerated tap water (4-5°C)
- Lake Models and Temperature
Density Stratification Worksheets (for students completing the
directed study lesson)
Time Required
Three hours
Curriculum Connections
Chemistry - dissolving, polarity,
hydrogen
bonds, cohesion,
surface
tension, adhesion,
capillary
action, density,
specific
heat, heat
of vaporization, universal
solvent
WOW Curriculum Links
Thermal
Stratification, Heat Budgets of
Lakes
Part
1
Knowledge Base
The WOW
data visualization tools can help illustrate the changes in temperature
and density during a year (see Figure 1). These changes could also be
demonstrated by advancing the Profile
Plotter through several sampling periods or by creating graphs
in Excel. The
WOW website resources for teachers and students includes several movies.
The movies will take awhile to download (they are 2 - 5 Mb), but are
useful illustrations of lab demonstrations showing thermal stratification
and mixing in water. Check out the following links to see the kinds
of thermal effects your students can demonstrate using simple lab materials.
You will need the Quicktime
Plug-in from Apple (no support for OS X) to view these movies.
-
Movie
1 - Here's what happens when warmer water (green) enters the surface
of a lake in winter. The second addition shows that the warm water
is buoyant (less dense) than the cold water and therefore rises.
-
Movie
2 - Here's what happens when colder water enters a summer-stratified
lake.
-
Movie
3 - Same movie 2 without the dyed green epilimnion.
-
Movie
4 - See what happens to the epilimnion (mixed layer) and thermocline
during a storm. Did the lake mix?
-
Movie
5 - Same as movie 4, but with increased turbulence. See what starts
to happen when the class 5 tornado hits.
-
Movie
6 - Shows how stream sediment entering a lake or reservoir deposits
its load. Why does some material stay in the upper layer and some
crash to the bottom?
-
Movie
7 - An estuary is a 2-layer system with freshwater overlying salt
water. Here we see how freshwater behaves when added to each layer.
-
Movie
8 - Same as movie 7, but here we introduce water that is saltier
than the upper freshwater layer. Example: Hurricanes can "throw" huge
amounts of saltwater into coastal lakes. What happens to this water
and what might its impact be?
You
may want to display these for the students. This could be done either
during your initial discussions for this lesson, or as part of the discussion
and closure for the lesson.
Figure
1: Temperature Profile for Ice Lake

Figure
2. Temperature Profiles for Winter and Summer on Ice Lake
Directed Study - Lake Models
Refer students to the student
reading on the unique properties of water. The reading introduces
students to the unique structure of water, cohesion of water molecules,
water's specific heat, evaporation and
cooling, waters liquid
range, frozen lake density, density relationships of water, and water
as a universal solvent.
Student Inquiry - WOW Lake Profiles
Refer students to the student
reading on the unique properties of water. The reading introduces
students to the unique structure of water, cohesion of water molecules,
water's specific heat, evaporation and cooling, waters liquid
range, frozen lake density, density relationships of water, and water
as a universal solvent.
Experimental Design
Directed Study
Students create summer and winter lake models
based on density stratification (modified from R. Axler). The Lake
Models Worksheet provides directions for creating the lake models.
Ask students to hypothesize what will happen when hot water is added
to the summer and winter lake models.
Student Inquiry
Students play the role of a chemistry instructor.
They need to demonstrate typical summer and winter lake profiles to their
class. Ask them to write a 1-2 paragraph lesson plan detailing how
to
use WOW data to teach students about how water behaves in a lake environment.
Data Collection
Directed Study
Refer students to the appropriate section
on the Lake Models Worksheet.
Students need to collect and record the temperature of each model at
2 cm intervals.
Student Inquiry
Ask students what data they plan to collect
to develop a typical summer and winter lake. How do they plan to organize
the data? Remind students that their presentation must be clear for
their
students. They should collect the data from WOW.
Data Management and Analysis
Directed Study
Refer students to the worksheet.
They need to graph the temperature data. Remind them to label their
axes and legend and title their graph.
When the graphs are completed students should
fill a jar with hot water (from faucet) and add enough food coloring to
make it very red. They should forcefully inject it as deep as possible
into the winter lake model and observe how the water behaves. After students
have recorded observations for the winter lake model, they should fill
another jar with hot water and add food coloring to make it very red.
They should forcefully inject it as deep as possible into the summer lake
model and observe how the water behaves.
Student Inquiry Students should create graphs and/or tables
to display the WOW data. Remind them to label axes and legends and title
graphs and tables. Students should consider how to explain the graphs
and tables to their class.
Interpretation of Results
Directed Study
Refer students to the appropriate section
on the Lake Models Worksheet.
Students need to explain how each of the models responded to the injection
of hot water and provide a reason for that response. As time permits,
students can make up several jars of different temperature water (ice
water, 10-15 degrees C, hot, and hot plus a tablespoon of salt), and
inject each at different depths and observe the behavior of the water.
Student Inquiry
Students should reflect on conclusions that
their class might draw from the data. How can they help their students
reconsider any possible misunderstandings about lake profiles? What
other
data might help their students understand typical lake profiles?
Reporting Results
Directed Study
Ask students to share their results with
the class. Were there discrepancies among results? Can students provide
an explanation for the discrepancies? Students should turn in their worksheet.
Student Inquiry
After students complete Part 2, they should
create a lesson about typical lake profiles. It can be a written paper,
poster, oral report, or multi-media presentation. They should prepare
to answer any questions their class might have.
Part 2
Knowledge Base
Directed Study - Temperature Density
Stratification in WOW Lakes
Ask students to consider how to use WOW
data to replicate what they learned from the student reading and the
laboratory exercise. What WOW data might demonstrate temperature density
stratification?
Student Inquiry - Lake Models
Students need to consider the following
scenario - some students in the class are still a bit confused about
typical summer and winter lake profiles. How can a teacher demonstrate
the profiles in a laboratory? What questions can guide students thought
processes?
Experimental Design
Directed Study
Refer students
to the appropriate worksheet section. They need to use WOW temperature
data and the Profile
Plotter
to determine if the results from the lake models apply in an actual
lake environment. Ask students to consider what data might verify their
results.
Student Inquiry
Provide students the following materials
to create summer and winter lake models.
- two 5-10 gallon aquaria
- plastic ruler
- thermometer
- red food coloring
- 2 gallon carboy with valve/tygon tube/U-tube assembly
- salt
- Pasteur pipettes
- 5 gallons of refrigerated tap water (4-5 °C)
Students need to write a lesson plan detailing
how to use these materials to demonstrate typical summer and winter lake
profiles to their class.
Data Collection
Directed Study
Refer students to the appropriate worksheet
section. Students collect temperature data for Ice Lake on January 2,
1999 and July 2, 1999.
Student Inquiry
What do students expect to see in their
lake profiles? How do they plan to organize the data? Remind them that
their presentation must be clear for students. They should create their
lake profiles.
Data Management and Analysis
Directed Study
Refer students to the appropriate worksheet
section. Students graph the temperature data. Remind them to label axes
and legends and title their graphs.
Student Inquiry
Students should create graphs and/or tables
to display their results. Remind them to label their axes and legends
and title their graphs and tables. Did the results replicate the WOW
data?
Interpretation of Results
Directed Study
Refer students
to the appropriate worksheet section. Students determine when Ice Lake
became isothermic
and provide environmental conditions that contributed to making the
lake isothermic. They consider whether or not the analysis of Ice Lake
verifies the lab results and what additional data might confirm the
earlier results.
Student Inquiry
Ask students to reflect on what conclusions
their students might draw from the experiment. Does the experiment confirm
the WOW data? If not, why? How can they help their students reconsider
any possible misunderstandings about the lake profiles? What other
data
might help students understand typical lake profiles?
Reporting Results
Directed Study
Students should present their results to
the class and explain any problems with the data. Are results consistent
among the class? If not, why? Students should turn in their worksheet.
Student Inquiry
Students should use the data, tables, and
graphs to create a lesson about typical lake profiles. It can be a written
paper, poster, oral report, or multi-media presentation. They should
prepare
to answer any questions the class might have.
Extensions and Links
- Lessons for teaching biology to prospective K-12 teachers can be
found at http://www.biologylessons.sdsu.edu/classes/lab1/lab1.html
- The Universities Water Information Network disseminates information
of interest to the water resources community and all concerned with
water resources. Access at http://www2.uwin.siu.edu/WaterSites/index.html
- The Minnesota Water Resources Research Institute is another helpful
site. Its address is http://wrc.coafes.umn.edu/wrri/
Resources
- Campbell, Neil, (1996) Biology, (Fourth Edition). Benjamin
Cummings Publishing.
- Cole, G.C. (1988) Textbook of Limnology. Waveland Press:
Prospect Heights, IL
- Dorsey, Ernst N. (1968) Properties of Ordinary Water. New
York, Hafner Publishing.
- Monson, Bruce A. (1992) A Primer on Limnology (Second Edition).
Public Report Series #6. Water Resources Research Center: St. Paul,
MN.
- Wetzel, R.G. Limnology, (1983) W.B. Saunders Publishing.
|